Studies show rapid weight loss more effective for many dieters.
Phoenix, Arizona (PRWEB) February 20, 2005 -- It has been an accepted "fact" of weight loss dieting for years: lose no more than two pounds per week if you want to stay healthy and keep the weight off. A retrospective evaluation of 25 controlled diet studies conducted over the past two decades shows just the opposite. Dieters who lost weight the fastest had higher success rates both for achieving and maintaining their target weight than those who lost weight more slowly.
Variations of a protein-sparing modified fast (PSMF) or a very low calorie diet (VLCD) were used as the fast weight loss methods. These were compared to typical low calorie or low carbohydrate weight loss diets.
Those in the lowest calorie (PSMF) group reported less hunger and less preoccupation with eating than those consuming 1200 calorie diets. Adherence was also greater in the very low calorie and protein sparing fast groups. At 18 month follow up, 30% of women and 58% of men in the PSMF group had maintained their weight loss compared to 6% of dieters who lost weight by traditional calorie-counting. There was no significant difference between the groups in terms of exercise tolerance, resting metabolism or reported emotional stress.
Researchers speculate that the success of a PSMF diet may be related to several factors including less hunger, less focus on food and faster emotional gratification. Dr. Dana Myatt, bariatric family physician and author of the The Super Fast Diet (http://www.super-fast-diet.com), concurs.
"Speed of weight loss in the first two months, called the 'honeymoon period' of dieting, appears to be a key factor in keeping people motivated," Myatt explains. But there is a caution. According to Myatt, "These positive results were seen in highly controlled studies where nutritional intake was carefully regulated. It is not simply a matter of eating a very low calorie diet. The diet must contain specific amounts of protein and nutrients in order to cause fast fat loss, not lean muscle loss. When done correctly, this type of diet appears superior to slower weight loss programs, especially for people in otherwise good health who have 40 or more pounds to lose."
###
|
